Measured reality behind the hype: the market leader got 93 % right on coin types in the only independent test ever run — and 40 % on grades. Six global players, one French outsider, zero honest French tests exist. Real measurements coming.
Two disclosures up front. (1) One app in this comparison, CoinROI, is owned by the operator of this website; it is marked throughout and scored by the same sourced rules as everyone else. (2) This page is currently an aggregate: every number is published by a named third party, linked, and dated. Our own measurement pass (reference coin set, double-scans, billing checks, network capture) is in progress and will replace this section-by-section as results land — see “What we will measure”.
Why this page exists
Every English “review” of coin scanner apps is a vendor blog, an AI script, or a paid placement; French coverage is one Les Numériques test of a single app (2025-09-25) and everything else is store chatter. This is the cross-checked map of all eight global players, with every number attributed and dated — and an announced measurement protocol that the whole category has never faced.
This niche is a gold rush with no gold: 69 coin-identification apps tracked in September 2026, 30 of them launched in the previous 18 months, and the two market leaders (CoinSnap and CoinIn) alone account for roughly 84 % of all review velocity while the 30 newcomers split the remaining 7 % (Appaloma, data 2026-09-01). CoinSnap alone is estimated by third-party trackers at $250k+/month revenue and 6,050 new App Store reviews per month. Meanwhile the loudest user complaint across the whole niche is not misidentification — it is trial billing: 93 billing complaints across the 12 leaders, “trial charged instantly despite 7-day promise” being the single most repeated phrase.
The 8 players at a glance
| App (developer) | Platforms | Price model | Traction (third-party) | Independent test data |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CoinSnap (Next Vision, CN) | iOS+Android | 10 free scans, then $3.99/wk–$39.99/yr | 294,507 iOS reviews (+6,050/mo); 10M+ Play; est. $250k+/mo | CoinWeek 2023: ID 93 %, grading 40 %, ancient 0 % |
| Coin ID (AIBY, Miami/Kyiv) | iOS+Android (Android unmaintained since 06/2023) | $4.99/wk–$39.99/yr, 3-day trial w/ card | 1M+ Play, ~45k iOS notes 4.5★; $100–200k/mo est. | None. Store reviews FR/DE/PL report repeated misIDs |
| Coinoscope (Miccron, since 2017) | iOS+Android | Free (15 valuations/day, ads), Pro $0.99/mo–$29.99 lifetime | ~2.6M installs, ~29k new/30 days; 80k web visits/mo | No controlled test; recommended by r/coins FAQ; Numista forum measured 85–99 % by user (2019) |
| Maktun (SIA Numex, Riga; roots RU 2018) | iOS+Android+AppGallery | Free w/o ads; Pro €8.99/mo–€69.99/yr (full export behind top tier) | 1M+ Play (7.8k ratings); weak iOS (~90 FR ratings) | One “75 % ID” figure — published in an affiliate funnel; treat as unverified |
| HeriBase ex-HeritCoin (Open Sky New Media HK, subsidiary of Weipaitang) | Android-first (5M+), iOS new | 3 scans/day + ads; $39.99/yr; paid “expert” appraisals $29.99–59.99 | 5M+ Play, ~75k ratings; ~420k downloads/mo (AppBrain) | Its own 12-coin benchmark (83 % vs CoinSnap 75 %) — quoted by no third party; disclosed as self-authored |
| CoinKnow (SenseWake, Dec 2025) | iOS | Subscription + paid reports | ~1,623 ratings 4.4★ US | Zero independent tests; instead buys sponsored placements at scale (The Print “Brandit”, student-newspaper listicles) |
| ChatCoin (ChatCoin Global, Sep 2025) | iOS | Freemium | ~1,953 ratings 4.6★ US | None found |
| CoinROI (ObviousIdea, FR) — our app | iOS | Pay-as-you-go credits from €0.99, no subscription | 3 App Store ratings; zero external visibility | None yet — it is in this list to be tested, not trusted |
1. CoinSnap — the incumbent to beat (and to bill you)
Chinese-based Next Vision Limited. Claims “99 % recognition, 300,000+ types”. What independent data actually shows: the only real media test ever run (CoinWeek, March 2023) measured 93 % correct coin type, 40 % correct grade, 0 % on ancient coins, and flagged that the terms grant CoinSnap a perpetual worldwide licence to every photo you upload. A competitor-run benchmark (HeriBase, 2026-09-16, disclosed as non-independent) still measured 12/12 types but only 9/12 varieties and the fastest scan time of any app (7.7 s mean). Consumer platforms document the business model: JustUseApp’s NLP pass over 296,413 reviews logs 58 service complaints — instant charging despite 7-day trials, unrequested annual renewals, no contact channel; 14 % of the last 12 months’ reviews mention billing. The US numismatics community is blunt: r/coins’ own FAQ warns against the app. CoinWeek’s grading verdict stands until re-measured: identification is genuinely good; values and grades are not trustworthy. The only French-language work on this app is Les Numériques’ single-app test of 2025-09-25 — no French lab has compared the category.
2. Coin ID (AIBY) — big marketing machine, unmaintained Android
AIBY (legal seat Miami, teams Kyiv; portfolio includes Plantum, Fonts Art) runs Coin ID as an ads-first subscription app: $4.99/week or $39.99/year with a 3-day card-on-file trial. Third-party market data (Sensor Tower + Adapty + AppRank, collected 2026-11): 1M+ Android installs, ~45k iOS ratings, est. $100–200k/month — top markets US, Germany, France. The red flags: AppBrain shows no Android update since June 2023 while iOS iterates; user reviews in three languages document the same failure mode — “3 different results for the same 2 € commemorative, none correct” (FR), “no post-2023 € coin recognized” (DE), weekly-billing disputes with “GOOGLE AIBY INC” card statements generating dispute-bait SEO pages. No independent test of any kind exists in English, French, German, Polish or Ukrainian. Sensor Tower/Adapty rank estimates: ~#133–165 Reference — visible, funded by ads, untested by anyone.
3. Coinoscope — the 2017 veteran and the privacy question
The oldest scanner (Play Sept 2017, iOS Jan 2018), ~2.6M installs, still updated (Android build seen 2026-10-12). Structure is different: visual comparison against a catalog (~300k coins, ~120k banknotes, sourced from Numista/Colnect/uCoin) with manual country/type filters instead of one-tap AI, free 15 valuations a day, no forced subscription — which is why r/coins recommends it in its FAQ where the AI apps are warned against. A forum user measured 85–99 % identification success on world coins back in 2019; nobody has re-measured it. Store ratings are mediocre (3.0–3.7) mostly over advertising — French reviewers report dating-site ads — and one App Store report accuses the app of shipping coin photos to data brokers; no media has ever verified this claim. We will, with a network capture. Web traffic ~80k visits/month (WebVetted). The anti-subscription control case.
4. Maktun — the collection manager, mislabeled “Spanish”
Frequently assumed Spanish; actually SIA Numex (Riga, Latvia), product lineage Russian (package ru.vlcoins.catalog, privacy policy dated 2018-02-28), with heavy Spanish-language marketing and real traction in Latin America (Mexican press Milenio, Brazilian and Mexican YouTube). 1M+ Play downloads but only ~7,800 ratings; iOS negligible. Its strengths are catalog depth (~300k coins incl. USSR and obscure issues), a genuinely free ad-free tier, full collection management with PDF/XLS/CSV export — and its weaknesses are documented by its own users: US-auction-based price guides “matching no reality”, blind photo ID failing on worn coins, 10–15 s latency, full export paywalled behind the €69.99/yr tier. The only numeric “test” (75 % ID) comes from an affiliate article funneling readers to a rival — unverified. No web app despite the marketing site.
5. HeriBase (ex-HeritCoin) — 5M downloads and a benchmark nobody quotes
The quiet giant: 5M+ Google Play downloads, ~75,000 ratings at 4.7, ~420,000 downloads/month (AppBrain). Ownership is opaque: Open Sky New Media Limited (HK, incorporated 2024-02-08) is a foreign subsidiary of Weipaitang, a Chinese collectibles marketplace — established not by marketing but by a WIPO UDRP decision (2025). HeriBase published its own 12-coin benchmark claiming 83 % accuracy vs CoinSnap 75 % — with an honest disclosure that the authors are the HeriBase team — and no third party has ever cited, reproduced or criticized it. Meanwhile Google Play FR reviews report a 2 € French commemorative valued at face (2 € vs real 11–60 €) and a bug that wiped a 700-coin collection (Jan 2026); EN reviews report 3-day trials requiring a card and ~$39.95 charged. App Store’s suspiciously unanimous 5★ (≈70 reviews, app relaunched 2026-06-03) vs Play’s 4.7/75k is itself a data point. Massive install base, zero independent verification, 254 self-hosted SEO articles in 8 languages.
6–7. CoinKnow and ChatCoin — the paid-placement wave
Two 2025-2026 entrants with real but small audiences (~1.6k and ~2.0k iOS ratings). CoinKnow is the industry’s lesson in distribution-over-product: it buys sponsored articles inside genuinely respected outlets — The Print’s “Brandit” commercial desk, listicles planted in US student newspapers (The Emory Wheel, CU Independent) — plus press releases attacking CoinSnap. No independent test exists for either. They matter to this comparison as market signals, not as benchmarks.
8. CoinROI — our own app, marked and disclosed
iOS-only French indie app (ObviousIdea — this site’s operator), May 2026, three App Store ratings, zero press coverage anywhere. It bets against the subscription economy: pay-as-you-go credits from €0.99, and four price references per coin (AI estimate, metal value, Numista catalog, live listings) instead of one opaque number. It has no independent test either — including itself in this comparison means it will be judged by the same protocol as the rest, and fail publicly if it fails.
Excluded (and why it matters)
Coinr AI, CoinSnapper, Coin Identifier Price/Value: 0 ratings, no coverage; Coinr’s App Store page 404s across 22 storefronts and its only “#1 ranking” is published on its own developer’s site (Wild Index). A growing share of “review” content in this niche is vendor-authored or AI-generated — which is exactly the hole a measured review is meant to fill.
What we will measure (protocol locked, rig being built)
The category’s published data is stale (CoinWeek’s test is from 2023), single-app (Les Numériques 2025), self-interested (HeriBase, CoinKnow funnels) or AI-generated. Our measurement pass will publish, per app, iOS and Android: (1) identification of type and variety on a fixed reference set including worn and European coins, ground truth validated against Numista by a human; (2) the double-scan test — same coin, two scans, measuring the price incoherence users report ($1 then $80) which nobody has ever quantified; (3) quoted value vs human-verified median of recent sold listings; (4) real cost of 100 scans, subscription vs credits; (5) billing behaviour during trial windows; (6) a network capture checking where coin photos actually go (Coinoscope’s data-broker accusation included); (7) export and data-loss behaviour. When each section lands, it replaces the sourced aggregate above, dated.
Billing models, re-checked 15 November 2026
We pulled the current in-app purchase prices for every app above straight from its own App Store listing on 15 November 2026 and kept dated snapshots of each page. Two apps bill without any subscription — CoinROI (pay-as-you-go credit packs, no expiry) and MünzCheck (one-time AI-scan packs, no expiry) — while the rest of the visible category uses auto-renewing subscriptions. Disclosure, again: CoinROI is our own app; this comparison follows the same disclosure rules as the rest of the page.
| App | Billing | Prices observed (storefront, 15 Nov 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| CoinROI (ObviousIdea) | Credits, pay-as-you-go, no subscription | €0.99 / €1.99 / €4.99 credit packs, no expiry (FR storefront) |
| MünzCheck (Heinz Meier) | One-time scan packs, no subscription | 25 scans €1.99, 100 scans €5.99, Pro €9.99 one-time (LU storefront; $1.99/$4.99/$6.99–8.99 on the US storefront) |
| CoinSnap: Coin Identifier | Auto-renewing subscription, 7-day trial | $3.99–$39.99 per plan (US storefront) |
| Coin Identifier™ (ScanCoins) | Auto-renewing subscription | $5.99/week or $29.99/year (US storefront) |
| Coin Identifier: Value & ID | Auto-renewing subscription | €6.99/week or €34.99/year (LU storefront) |
Apple prices vary by storefront and can change without notice; every figure above comes from the app’s own App Store page, checked on the stated date. A full line-by-line comparison — including what each value estimate does and does not guarantee — is published on the CoinROI site (English / French).
Frequently asked questions
Do coin scanner apps detect rare coins?
Partially. Independent measurements show ~93 % correct coin-type identification on modern US coins (CoinWeek, 2023) but about half of that on varieties — the errors that actually make a coin rare — and 0 % on ancient coins.
Are the values shown by coin apps accurate?
No published lab has verified them, and user-measured cases are harsh: a 10 French francs Jimenez quoted at €0.94–2.34 vs €9 market, the same coin quoted $1 and $80 in two scans, a British 10 oz gold coin read as 5 oz. Treat in-app values as unverified guesses.
Is CoinSnap a scam?
The identification works — 93 % type accuracy in the one independent test. The billing is the scam-shaped part: 93 trial-billing complaints across the niche leaders, 14 % of CoinSnap’s recent reviews mention billing, and its terms take a perpetual licence to your photos.
Which coin scanner app has no subscription?
Coinoscope is free with daily limits and ads; Maktun is free without ads but paywalls exports; CoinROI (French indie, iOS) sells pay-as-you-go credits instead of subscriptions. None of the three is independently tested yet.
Aggregate synthesis BR-AGG-2026-11-02. Third-party figures belong to their named sources and dates; measurement pass results will supersede them, published with raw data. Conflicts of interest disclosed above.